I have finally succumbed to an urge to publish a “top ten” style list of the boardgames I most enjoy. I have resisted calling it a “top ten” because I’m fully aware that my experience and knowledge is not as expansive enough to justify such a label. There are many, many games which I know have great reputations and which I have never played (or sometimes, even seen on the table). Titles such as Twilight Imperium, Cosmic Encounter, Blood Rage, Descent, Gloomhaven and all the Arkham/Eldridge Horror series immediately spring to mind. Instead what I have imagined is a ‘desert island’ type of situation, where I am faced with access to a limited (10) number of games for the foreseeable future. I assume Elaine will accompany me to the ‘island’ and that we will encounter ‘new’ potential players, but we don’t know what their gaming preferences will be. I therefore have planned my list to be representative of the wide expanse of gaming styles, mechanisms and genres.
I have set myself a few ground rules. I will allow inclusion of some expansions to the core game if they can be fitted into the base game box (but for one of my games I would ideally take some additional material). I also assume I have access to the full range of gaming miscellanea; dice, playing cards, pens and paper etc. I also have not ranked the games in the list, so the game listed at number 2 is not necessarily a “better” game than that listed at number 3. Attempting to do this just proved too hard and, actually, did not add any further value to the listing process.
Such lists are always a very personal and subjective exercise. I would gratefully welcome comments and alternative suggestions from readers, and such contributions would be useful to inspire me to get or try out games new to me.
(1) The first game I’m going to list is a dedicated 2-player, filler style of game. I think this category of game is very important; sometimes you just want to fill a short period of time with a small, quick, light game. This is the type of game Elaine and I would take on holiday and play in those hours between getting back to our lodgings and before going out to dinner. This is a time to put your feet up and recuperate after a full day of site-seeing. I have selected Schotten Totten to fill this requirement, but it was a close call, just edging out Lost Cities. Schotten Totten is a small, simple card game that can be a real brain-burner. There is excellent re-playability and every game poses a challenge. Interestingly, we have never played the game variants included in the box because we find the base game to be sufficient, but maybe the isolation of a desert island would encourage us to try these additions. I think the factor which moved it ahead of Lost Cities is its depth; Schotten Totten causes you to really analyse your card play and the bluffing element comes into play more. I would highly recommend Schotten Totten and would consider it a vital inclusion when packing for holiday trips.
(2) I definitely want a tile-laying game and Carcassonne fits the bill perfectly. This game is a classic and can be easily taught to new players. I like the scaling to fit varying player counts; it works OK with just 2 players but equally good with 4 or 5 players. The randomness of the tile draw gives good replay ability, there are different routes to victory with a ‘hint’ of take-that. I would take the traditional base game with the ‘River’ start tiles added. There are numerous small expansions to the game, many of which I think are interesting, but I have found they tend to get played once or twice before being left to sit on the shelf. So, I am happy to leave them behind and just play the base game. Carcassonne has been re-skinned many times to fit different themes with some rules adjustments; you can simply choose the theme you enjoy the most. The original theme actually works best for me, because we have spent a number of very enjoyable holidays touring South-West France, visiting Carcassonne and surrounding towns and castles, so it therefore invokes happy memories.
(3) Deck building is such an enjoyable mechanism. It has been widely used in many great games, and therefore demands representation in any games collection. Dominion fits this niche for me, I still
remember the pleasure I got when I first encountered this game. It’s addictive, and this is one possible reason for the backlash it has engendered amongst some gamers; every year there seems to be another (large box) expansion, with more cards, combos and rule additions. I therefore would restrict myself to the base game with a single expansion only. In fact, I would strongly recommend most gamers to follow a single expansion policy for Dominion; the game appeal suffers with the more stuff you get, and it becomes a drag! I am sure there are card types I own that I have never yet used in play, and the number of possible card combos is huge. My personal choice of expansion would be Prosperity because I like purchasing the higher value cards. Another common criticism of Dominion is the lack of theme. I feel you should play Dominion to simply enjoy the card drafting mechanism and the lack of theme is largely irrelevant. Other, more thematic, games of a similar type tend to distract, divert and dilute the card draft mechanics.
(4) The next game on my list is very theme heavy i.e. Dungeon Petz. This game also encapsulates the worker placement mechanic nicely. The game uses iconography brilliantly; the game flow, mechanics and options are nicely illustrated, easily followed, and most importantly, fit the theme perfectly. Players face tough choices about where to place their imps/workers, they need to think ahead, planning for the growing requirements of their ‘petz’, and which competitions/customers are coming up. Amazingly, players frequently become so caught up with the engaging theme, that they knowingly make less than optimal decisions because they have become emotionally ‘attached’ to the particular ‘petz’ that they have raised. Getting those ‘tear’ cubes is so sad (even if there is a customer who wants sad ‘petz’), and the build up of the brown cubes in cages is a source of shame! I love this game and have never felt the need to buy the expansion, although smaller expansions with simply more ‘petz’ would work well. The base game depth is fine for me, and I don’t feel the need to expand the options available. I am surprised that the game has not generated a range of miniature models with clicker bases to replace the card ‘petz’ in the game. If I was more skilled in modelling with clay, I would make my own ‘petz’, and maybe this would be a good project in the future.
(5) No essentials list could be complete without the classic set collection game, ‘Ticket to Ride’. There are so many geographic variants, but my personal favourite is ‘Europe’. I like the presence of
tunnels and ferries, and the stations make the game less cut-throat. I don’t feel the need to include the ‘1912’ expansion, whereas I feel the ‘USA’ game does benefit from the ‘1910’ expansion. I have played a fair few of the different Ticket to Ride versions and they all give interesting games. Individuals all have their own favourites and I’m happy to play any that get brought to the table. I don’t think the choice simply corresponds to the geography the player is familiar with, for example I’m not overly fond of the ‘UK’ version (too many additional rules to expand the range and technology).
(6) As a wargamer I have to include a combat game. My choice would be Battlelore-2 with the expansions for both the red and blue forces. Ideally I would also like to take the purple army to provide greater variability, but these do not fit in the original box, so probably would have to be left behind. The hex game board allows for simple, clear-cut rules and the opposed scenario generation system provides for interesting terrain and force placement. The card-driven command choice mechanism is clever and I really like it, but I don’t find it translates well into ‘historical’ backgrounds. This is a major reason why I’m not a fan of ‘sister’ games like Memoir ’44; I don’t think the game mechanisms simulate the command problems and decision making found on a historical battleground. I think this criticism equally applies to the combat dice rolling, but in a fantasy background, these issues are irrelevant. In a fantasy scenario no-one can argue a point based on precedence; if a designer wants to represent his Orcs as peaceful and caring, then that’s fine, he is simply diverting from the ‘accepted’ norm. Therefore, I think the game mechanics found in Battlelore are great, but only in a fantasy setting; they fall short when translated to historical conflicts. The magic aspects of fantasy combat are also handled in a streamlined way by Battlelore, and the whole package gives a fast paced game, packed with interesting decisions.
(7) I enjoy the co-operative genre of boardgames a lot, and the giant of the market is Pandemic. This game has added personal appeal because I am a retired virologist, and the game ‘models’ some of
(9) The next game on my list involves a role selection mechanism, and that is Glory to Rome. I love the multiple uses of the cards and the combo possibilities of the buildings. When you choose a role, other players can follow, so players are constantly engaged. There is a lot of depth and strategy, and I’m sure I am still a long way from playing effectively. I own the cartoon-style version of the game and personally like the graphics used. I have seen the ‘Black Box’ version and found it to be uninspiring on the table. I am not sure how easy it is to get Glory to Rome at the moment, so my alternative choice in this category would be San Juan, which has a similar role selection mechanic and is less complex and easier to understand.
So, there it is, my personal list of 10 ‘essential’ games. Even as I write I can think of numerous omissions, and the temptation to add more games is very strong. I can see I have included many ‘classic’ games, but I think such games are considered ‘classic’ for a very good reason; that is they are inherently good games. I am concerned that I have not included any puzzle or race games, but I set the line at 10 games, so some excellent games had to be dropped. I would feel sad to think that Catan, 7 Wonders, 5 Tribes and others would be left behind to gather dust, but maybe my stay on the ‘island’ would turn out to be reasonably short.